Is rare Malt Whisky a good investment?

80

By Asp52

Malt whiskey investment: the new wine?

 

Financial analysts in 2009 pointed to the performance of investment in vintage wine as a safer and more profitable venture than traditional blue chip companies. Vintage wines and champagnes have a proven market value and if the asset is kept in optimum condition has an earning potential that is almost unrivaled. These commodities out performed the stock market in their returns. The assets obviously will reach a higher price when the economy is booming and it's ultimate consumer will ironically enough be the fund managers celebrating their financial success and foresight. In a London restaurant four major financial traders sat down for a lunch. The four bankers bill came to £96,000, the bottles of wine they consumed from the eateries wine cellar totalled £96,000. The bankers got their meals gratis due to the amount they spent on only four bottles of vintage wine. The question i am asking is could a similar level of performance be matched by investment in malt whiskey?

Origins of Whisky


Whisky has it roots in many different cultures and countries. Both Ireland and Scotland have a long history and valued prestige with the drink ,and some elitist connoisseurs of single malt will use their products as the benchmark of greatness. The brands of whisky and bourbons from USA, Canada, Australia or Japan cannot be overlooked for ground floor investment opportunities. Worldwide consumption of whiskey is still strong with India and China been large markets.The drink is drank in over 200 countries and the amount of whisky sold per year is massive.


Is whisky a good commodity?

Before we dismiss the idea out of hand that whisky can have the same collect-ability and potential for increasing its net worth, lets examine some facts. Wine and Champagne vintages have continued to increase in value. If wine has been rescued from a sunken wreck it has a greater value even if it is undrinkable. A single malt is more expensive now that most higher end wines which are available either online or from reputable wholesalers of beverages.I must clarify Single malt is usually distilled on one of the Celtic islands and not the blended whisky or scotch you see on optics in pubs ( these include Bells, Grants and Whyte and Mackay). With wine i am referring to wines over 5 or 6 years old at least, and generally the wine is sealed with a cork.

To prove whisky is a commodity i came across this recent small story concerning beverage company Diageo. Diageo has recently come up with a novel initiative to plug its pension deficit that will see it use barrels of whiskey as collateral.The company, owner of the brands Johnny Walker and Bushmills whiskey announced it had agreed a funding deal to transfer £500m worth of maturing whisky to trustees of its pension scheme. This would be sold back at a later date but generally capped to a mutually agreeable figure. Here is a potential investment opportunity as if the whisky is ever bottled it has a story attached to it.


101 Whiskies to Try Before You Die
Amazon Price: $10.84
List Price: $19.95
Jim Murray's Whisky Bible 2012
Amazon Price: $12.65
List Price: $19.95
The World Atlas of Whisky: More Than 350 Expressions Tasted - More Than 150 Distilleries Explored
Amazon Price: $17.95
List Price: $34.99

Rare Malt Whisky

Still not convinced? okay, the following are a couple of bottles of fine single malt. The malts are less than 70 years old and if you compare them to relevant vintages in the wine world i think its a good comparison.

  1. Bruichladdich Limited Edition 40 year old Whiskey. It was distilled on 24th October 1964.The batch was matured in fresh Bourbon casks. Now bottled as the oldest ever from this distillery, and is a limited edition of 500 bottles each valued and sold at ....£1,000 per bottle.
  2. Midleton 1996 This is a very rare Irish Whiskey, it is triple distilled by John Jameson & Son, aged to perfection and bottled in the year 1996. Each bottle is individually numbered and expect to pay about £245 per bottle.
  3. Glenfiddich 1937 64 Year Old 70cl bottle. This rare bottle is 40%ABV Distillery Bottled at Speyside. This Single Malt Scotch Whisky is the rarest Glenfiddich ever released. Just 61 bottles of spirit remained in the cask when it was bottled in 2001. At 64 years of age, it was also the world's oldest single malt whisky at the time of release. As such, and coming from such a famous distillery, it is one of the most collectable whiskies ever released, and makes headlines around the world every time a bottle comes up at auction. expect to pay upwards of £50,000.00

Comments

MyCommodity 22 months ago

Interesting thought there Asp52 about a huge pool of whisky assets in peoples' homes waiting to be tapped. We haven't actually thought about this, but perhaps we should. It is essentially the same as these 'We Buy Your Gold' companies that have been buying up peoples' domestic gold coins and trinkets that have been collecting dust in peoples' homes. But, obviously done for whisky. Perhaps the untapped stock out there might be smaller than gold because people have been tempted to crack open bottles and enjoy the malt!

We think we would need to offer a range of markets in Macallans and a few other whiskies that have the same kudos as things like Chateau Lafite Rothschild in wine. Aiming to have highly legitimate product offerings. As such, we may only be interested in acquiring whisky stock that ties in with this.

Who knows, plenty to think about.

There probably are merchants that would buy the whisky off these people, but in the same as the 'We buy your golds' of this world do with gold, we bet they would give you significantly less than the market price. There have been many reports about people selling gold in this way and receiving as little as 50% of the smelt down value of their gold...talk about inefficient. Sadly many of these people have had this in the family for generations, and get woed by the prices, even if they could have got more elsewhere.

Regards,

https://www.mycommodity.com/

Asp52 profile image

Asp52 Hub Author 22 months ago

Thank you for your kind comments, having looked again at your website i think it is a really good start of place for novice traders and for people with a long term view for profits. I think a lot of people would prefer to have something real as their investement rather than share certificates. Do you think there are a lot of vintage malts and wines gathering dusts in cupboards around the country and if so are you planning on having a facility on your website to track down these hidden treasures which are remaining untapped.

MyCommodity 22 months ago

Hi Asp,

Yes, we do believe that demand for the top end whisky has increased over the last decade, and are thinking about offering markets in investment grade whisky on our platform.

China and India are part of the great emerging market story in Asia indeed. If we were to offer whisky markets on our site, a client would not have to take their whisky to these markets, they could participate anywhere in the world.

Our model works as this: we hold these very fine whiskies in secure professional storage; the same amount of whisky can then be sold by the people who own the whisky on our site showing liquidity on the 'sell' side of the market; then we would ensure liquidity on the buy side of the market; and Eureka, you have a proper exchange market with super tight spreads for buying and selling whisky as part of your investment activity. Currently no such product exists for investors wanting to do this, and the costs of the existing options means the investor has to hold pretty long term just to break even.

The client could then manage this whisky investment, like all their other investments with us, through their account with us online.

Also like you article on gold by the way. Although we are not gold bugs per se, we aim to bring market efficiencies to phyical bullion investing.

Keep the blogs coming!

Regards,

https://www.mycommodity.com/

Oscar Waysider profile image

Oscar Waysider 22 months ago

sounds interesting as a new kind of an investment asset. looks like if there is some more research done, you can find quite a many new investment opportunities, and why shouldn't it be malt whysky?

Asp52 profile image

Asp52 Hub Author 22 months ago

Thanks for the feedback- correct me if I am wrong but china and India are

now the growth markets for whiskey at present. So anything of a vintage could

be maximised profit wise in that Market. I think it is something people can look into

as a small investement. Worst case scenario you can always drink the bottle on a very

special occasion. Do you wind there has been more demand for vintage whisky as a commodity compared to previous times?

MyCommodity 22 months ago

Thanks Asp52,

Completely agreed on how too many middle men make a market inefficent which ultimately cost the ends user (the consumer) more money. Wine and Whisky investment are good examples. For example - the best distilleries and chateaux will not sell direct to the public, but through a tiered system of merchants and dealers. Often a number of middle men all taking a slice. That's why we try to use technology to create a true exchange market where customers can transact with each other away from all middle men.

Your point about research cannot be over made. With whisky, we belive serious research into the actually nectar to invest in is first, then as you say shopping around for best price. We think the most prestigous marques are best, and are big fans of Macallan.

Whisky is indeed a long term investment, and like wine is seen as a 'decaying asset', thus exempt from CGT.

It seems top end whisky benefits from a similar brand and franchise as Bordeaux wine does, if different geographically. The demand from the East is very strong and not a new thing. We know of Asian institutions buying distilleries like Bowmore decades ago.

Regards,

https://www.mycommodity.com/

Asp52 profile image

Asp52 Hub Author 22 months ago

Thank you for the feedback, i think your website is a very good and for serious traders a good idea to check out. Hopefully others will see your mini stock market and have good use for it. The middle men usually take a large wedge of any transaction, I think the key here is to do your research and buy as cheap as possible a whiskey " vintage" you are confident will prove a good investment. I think at present if trading in whisky futures you will expect the middle man to take his percentage it will hopefully be well covered by eventual profits. It is a long term strategy so patience is crucial.

MyCommodity 22 months ago

we have started making wine markets to bring professional market efficiences and transparency to wine investing.

Perhaps we should do it for whisky as well?

The whisky market for individuals to invest in seems to be inefficient like wine, with +20% bid offer spreads being the norm. What this means in reality is that if you buy your bottle of Macallan 1965 for £1000, if you wanted to sell it the next day the merchant would only offer you £800 to buy it back.

Not only is this very inefficient for the individual, but it means such an investment has to appreciate 20% in value just to break even. Surely the market is not serving the customer properly here and middle men are taking a huge cut!

We hope to change all this through a live auction market for precious commodities and alternatives. A mini stock exchange if you like for participating in such investments.

A lot of what we do is in response to client demand and feedback, so please contact us with your feedback.

Regards,

https://www.mycommodity.com/

Submit a Comment
Members and Guests

Sign in or sign up and post using a hubpages account.



    • No HTML is allowed in comments, but URLs will be hyperlinked
    • Comments are not for promoting your Hubs or other sites

    Please wait working